Project

General

Profile

Bug #1199

Inaccurate seeking in WebM (and Ogg Opus) audio files

Added by Nyan Pasu 3 months ago. Updated 28 days ago.

Status:
New
Priority:
Minor
Assignee:
-
Category:
plugins/ffaudio
Target version:
-
Start date:
November 04, 2022
Due date:
% Done:

0%

Estimated time:
Affects version:

Description

In WebM audio files downloaded through yt-dlp (Opus) or encoded myself (Opus and Vorbis), Audacious's seeking is extremely imprecise. In some cases, I click on different timestamps in the seek bar, seconds apart in a given file, yet playback jumps to the same point.

In testing:

  • .flac and Ogg Vorbis seeking are always accurate to sub-second precision.
  • With WebM (Opus/Vorbis) files, clicking ahead of the current play point can jump up to ~5 seconds ahead (to the next "start point" of some sort) which is quite awful. Clicking back into an already-played and decoded section of a file which has played continuously from the file's beginning is accurate. Clicking forward or back from a forward click is inaccurate, and usually jumps to the same "start point".
  • With Ogg Opus files, seeking jumps up to 1-2 seconds behind the click point. Seeking into already-decoded audio is not more accurate than seeking ahead (unlike WebM). This is mostly less bad than WebM, but still inaccurate.

The worst part to me is that Audacious's play time viewer and seek bar act as though you've seeked to the exact time in the song, yet the actually playing audio can be multiple seconds off the point you clicked. So effectively the program is lying to you, and with many songs I thought I was just really bad at seeking to the right spot, not realizing Audacious was at fault.

I've attached a set of test audio files containing identical pitched sweeps (aside from lossy compression), designed so you can easily hear the exact point in time you seeked to (even if Audacious's play time viewer is inaccurate).

audacious-seek-test.zip (748 KB) audacious-seek-test.zip Nyan Pasu, November 04, 2022 03:38

History

#1 Updated by Thomas Lange 28 days ago

  • Category set to plugins/ffaudio

Audacious 4.3 will add a native decoder plugin for Ogg Opus files.
This won't fix the bug for WebM files though. They are still played via FFmpeg (ffaudio plugin).

P.S. Thanks for the good bug report and sample files.

Also available in: Atom PDF