Project

General

Profile

Feature #609

Allow adding files to other than playing playlist via D-Bus

Added by Daniel Bedrenko almost 9 years ago. Updated almost 7 years ago.

Status:
Closed
Priority:
Minor
Assignee:
-
Category:
audtool
Target version:
3.9
Start date:
December 31, 2015
Due date:
% Done:

100%

Estimated time:
Affects version:
3.7

Description

Prior to v3.7 the behaviour was to enqueue files to the playlist currently selected in the interface, rather than the currently playing playlist. The former is much better as I can manage and manipulate my playlists without having to interrupt the playback of my music.

Steps to reproduce:

1) Create "Playlist1" with 1 song. And "Playlist2" with no songs.
2) Double-click on the song of "Playlist1" so it starts playing.
3) Click on "Playlist2" tab so that this playlist is selected and visible.
4) Add any music file with `audacious -e /path/to/file.mp3`.

Result:
"file.mp3" is added to "Playlist1"

Expected result:
"file.mp3" is added to "Playlist2".

PS: Thank you for your work on the best music player on Linux. Been loving it for the past 4 years :)

History

#1 Updated by John Lindgren almost 9 years ago

  • Tracker changed from Bug to Feature
  • Subject changed from Enqueuing files adds to currently playing playlist to Allow adding files to other than playing playlist via D-Bus
  • Category set to core
  • Affects version deleted (3.7.1)

The change was intentional, was documented in the release notes, and was made to solve #557, so not a bug.

Here's the problem. Some commands must still apply to the playing playlist; they just don't make sense otherwise. So where do you draw the line? If we make some commands apply to the playing playlist and others apply to the displayed playlist, then the behavior is inconsistent, making it difficult to know what to expect.

For example, let's suppose we make audtool playlist-insurl apply to the displayed playlist. Then for consistency, you would also expected audtool playlist-delete to work the same, right? But now you've broken the common use case of removing the currently playing song using audtool playlist-delete `audtool playlist-position`.

Do you understand now why the change was made?

#2 Updated by Daniel Bedrenko almost 9 years ago

Yes, I understand why the change was made, and I agree that intuitiveness and consistency should prevail. Sorry, I didn't think of checking the full release notes (I only checked the fixed bugs on the release post on the homepage).

But it is quite an inconvenient change in a common use case: if I'm in the process of organising my music I can't have a song playing in the background; I must interrupt playback so that I can add tracks to other playlists. This is annoying in itself, but is also inefficient: sometimes--in the process of organising--I want to listen to an added track to ascertain which playlist it should be added to, so in order to do this I must completely cease any activities involving adding tracks to other playlists (as this would interrupt playback).

Also, the behaviour of changing the playlist by playing the playlist--in order to add tracks to it--is ugly, because I have to immediately pause playback as I don't want to lose the remembered playback position in the playlist I switched to.

Is a reasonable solution to add a switch `--use-display-playlist` to `audtool` or command-line `audacious` that would make all other command switches in this invokation to apply to the display playlist, rather than the currently playing playlist?

#3 Updated by John Lindgren over 8 years ago

D B wrote:

Is a reasonable solution to add a switch `--use-display-playlist` to `audtool` or command-line `audacious` that would make all other command switches in this invokation to apply to the display playlist, rather than the currently playing playlist?

Sorry for the delayed response. Yes, that would be a reasonable solution; I just haven't had any time to think about how to implement it on the D-Bus side.

#4 Updated by John Lindgren over 7 years ago

I finally got around to implementing this; the --select-displayed switch will revert to roughly the pre-3.7 behavior:
https://github.com/audacious-media-player/audacious/commit/8310b536b44bbb06b868df6ceb7aca33d5d77536

#5 Updated by John Lindgren over 7 years ago

  • Category changed from core to audtool
  • Status changed from New to Closed
  • Target version set to 3.9
  • % Done changed from 0 to 100

#6 Updated by Daniel Bedrenko almost 7 years ago

Great, thank you! Every day I use this great music player :)

Also available in: Atom PDF